Institutional Racism in Psychiatry

There has been growing concern that institutional racism may be contributing to the overrepresentation of Black patients in mental health settings. Despite ethnic minorities making up only 9% of the UK population, the 2010 ‘Count me in Census’ found that 23% of inpatients and those on CTOs were from Black and minority ethnic groups. Black minority groups also had higher rates of admission, detention, and seclusion.

While patient factors, such as higher rates of mental illness in Black minority groups, may contribute to these findings, there is also a suggestion of inherent racism within psychiatry. This may manifest in perceptions of Black and minority ethnic patients being at greater risk, as well as systemic factors that disadvantage these groups.

It is important to address these issues and work towards a more equitable and just mental health system for all patients, regardless of their ethnicity.

Institutional Racism in Psychiatry

There has been growing concern that institutional racism may be contributing to the overrepresentation of Black patients in mental health settings. Despite ethnic minorities making up only 9% of the UK population, the 2010 ‘Count me in Census’ found that 23% of inpatients and those on CTOs were from Black and minority ethnic groups. Black minority groups also had higher rates of admission, detention, and seclusion.

While patient factors, such as higher rates of mental illness in Black minority groups, may contribute to these findings, there is also a suggestion of inherent racism within psychiatry. This may manifest in perceptions of Black and minority ethnic patients being at greater risk, as well as systemic factors that disadvantage these groups.

It is important to address these issues and work towards a more equitable and just mental health system for all patients, regardless of their ethnicity.

Research has consistently shown that out-patient services, whether they are general of specialized eating disorder clinics, are more likely to be cost-effective than in-patient care. The majority of patients with eating disorders can be effectively managed in out-patient clinics, with only a small percentage requiring in-patient care. When comparing outpatient treatment models, including general child and adolescent mental health services, with in-patient treatment, there were significant improvements in all groups at different points during follow-up, with no significant differences between the two types of treatment. The availability of out-patient care is associated with a lower rate of admission to inpatient units. Clinically and economically, lengthy in-patient stays are not recommended, as they are associated with worse outcomes, particularly when they disrupt the patient’s life, such as their work, studies, of time away from family.